Do genetics play a role in intelligence? What about the environment a person grows up in? Explore some of the evidence that exists for each of these factors, as well as how researchers attempt to answer these questions in the following lesson.
Nature vs. Nurture
There are two major areas of disagreement in the study of intelligence. One area involves a debate about the basic nature of intelligence. What is the other?The second debate in intelligence research focuses on one of the most prominent issues in every field of the social sciences. I am referring to the age old question of whether nature or nurture is the most important. So what plays a bigger role in intelligence? Are genetics the most important aspect or is it environment?Most researchers recognize that both nature and nurture influence intelligence.
Both genetics and the environment interact with one another in this process. However, it is less clear how much influence each one has. It can be difficult to separate the influences of heredity and environment, but there is a significant amount of information that can help us. Let’s look at the evidence supporting each side of this debate.
Some of the most convincing evidence for a genetic component to intelligence comes from twin studies.
There have been many studies that compare the IQ of identical twins and the IQ of fraternal twins. Identical twins share 100% of the same DNA because they come from the same fertilized egg. Fraternal twins come from two separate fertilized eggs and they share only 50% of the same DNA. Since both identical twins and fraternal twins share the same prenatal and home environments, any similarities or differences in the IQ of identical twins compared to fraternal twins can reasonably be attributed to DNA.It was found that identical twins have IQ scores that are more similar than the IQ scores of fraternal twins. Even identical twins who were raised in separate households were found to have IQ’s that were more similar than that of fraternal twins raised together. This means we can assume that genetic influences account for the similar IQ scores of identical twins.
Another way researchers have gathered evidence for the influence of heredity on IQ is through adoption studies. Adopted children share similar genetics to their biological parents, while their environment is more closely matched to that of their adoptive parents. The IQ scores of these adopted children have been found to be more closely related to their biological parents.
This provides evidence for a genetic component to intelligence as well.It is important to note that twin studies and adoption studies cannot completely separate genetic and environmental influences. These studies do, however, provide support for the idea that genetics play a role in the development of intelligence.
So, there’s evidence that genetics plays a role in IQ, but what about environment? There’s evidence from a number of different sources that indicates it has a significant role as well.
Remember the twin studies that we discussed earlier? Even though the IQ scores of all identical twins were more similar than those of fraternal twins, there was a difference in this similarity between identical twins who were raised together and those who were raised apart. Identical twins who were raised apart had IQ scores that were less similar than the IQ scores of identical twins who were raised together. The only reasonable way to account for this difference is environmental influence.Studies have also shown that exposure to toxic substances or severe malnutrition during prenatal periods or early in life can have an impact on neurological development. This can, in turn, have a long-term effect on intelligence.
Formal schooling has been shown to have an impact on intelligence as well. The simple act of going to school will increase a child’s IQ by a small amount. According to recent studies, children who attend school regularly have overall higher IQ scores than those who do not. A possible reason why school attendance affects IQ is that it provides a means for acquiring more advanced cognitive processes.
Another indicator of environmental impact on intelligence is the Flynn effect. The Flynn effect is a term used for a steady increase over the past few decades in people’s average performance on IQ tests. This improvement cannot be attributed to genetics because genes are passed down from one generation to the next. This means that the cause must be due to environmental factors. However, scientists have been unable to agree upon the specific environmental cause.
The Flynn effect could be due to better nutrition, better home environments, or better schooling just to name a few possible causes.
Most researchers recognize that both nature and nurture influence intelligence. Researchers have gathered evidence for the influence of heredity on IQ through twin studies and adoption studies. Identical twins have more similar IQ scores than fraternal twins and adopted children have IQ scores that relate more closely to their biological parents than adoptive parents. This provides evidence for a genetic component to intelligence.Researchers have also gathered evidence supporting an environmental link to intelligence through twin studies.
Identical twins raised together have more similar IQ scores than identical twins raised apart. Studies on malnutrition, exposure to toxic substances, education, and the Flynn effect support an environmental link as well. The Flynn effect is a term used for a steady increase over the past few decades in people’s average performance on IQ tests.Both genetics and the environment interact with one another and influence IQ.
However, it is less clear how much influence each has.
When this video lesson is completed, you should be able to:
- Understand the debate between IQ affected by genetics and environment
- Describe the studies of twins (identical and fraternal) for answers
- Define the Flynn effect on the steady rise in IQ scores overall